Cold Open
- Kat is slumped over the bar at The Middle C sound asleep snoring like a drunken sailor.
- Randi, Max, Sheila, and Gideon gently shake her and jab at how awfully tired she is.
- Carter tries to wake Kat up with his progressively louder and more irritated coughing.
- Kat finally startles awake when Carter accidentally dings a shot glass quietly.
- Carter asks why Kat is sleeping at his business and messing up his work flow.
- Kat tells Carter about the mess from puppy yoga class customers. Took all night to clean.
- Carter seems to lack sympathy for Kat’s problems as he continues to wipe down glasses.
- Kat complains to Carter about how hard her café is to run and that he wouldn’t get it.
- Carter looks incredulously at her and bets Kat she couldn’t survive a day running his bar.
- Kat takes that bet and raises the stakes to whoever caves first cleans the other’s toilets.
Title Card
Act 1
- Kat is happily shaking margaritas and sliding drinks across the bar, but drops everything.
- Max is playing old-timey piano music along with Kat’s bar mixing shenanigans.
- Gideon comes to the bar and starts mixing random drinks. He thinks he’s switching, too.
- Kat explains the switch is just her. Thinking more, she sends Gideon on a sabotage quest.
- Gideon objects, but Kat explains how cutthroat this competition with Carter is.
- Gideon feels wrong about messing with Carter, but Kat tempts him with an Ikea visit.
- Randi and Carter are pounding back espresso shots laughing and having a good time.
- Sheila comes into the cafe asking Carter what his plan is to sabotage Kat.
- Carter is confused, but Sheila clarifies Kat fights dirty and wants to put her in her place.
- Seeing Gideon make a weird beeline to the kitchen, Randi suggests Sheila sabotage.
- Carter starts to protest this, but Sheila interrupts him with an ominous “Say no more.”
- Kat starts giving away free booze to a few requests since she’s too awkward to say no.
- Kat is soon swamped with drinks. The bar fills up with Sheila’s retirement home friends.
- Kat answers the ringing bar phone to a health inspector announcing a surprise visit today.
- Max comes to help Kat and sees drunken elders and granny belly shots happening.
- Kat frantically explains the problem and Max reassures her that they will sort it all out.
- Kat points out everything unsanitary, like a large sweaty shirtless old man playing piano.
- Randi tries to make a latte for a customer, but sees that she is out of espresso beans.
- Randi goes to the kitchen to check the stock, but sees stacks of unrecognizable pastry.
- Gideon declares that he made his Amish friendship bread with all of the espresso beans.
- Gideon then spills the beans and confesses to sabotaging and his overwhelming guilt.
- Randi is frustrated with Gideon, but he soon realizes that his last loaf of bread is burning.
- Gideon grabs the fire extinguisher, but messes up the kitchen and foams Randi.
- Carter walks in to ask for Randi’s help with making latte art and is shocked at the scene.
- Randi explains they can’t make latte art because they have no espresso beans for lattes.
- Randi then tells Carter about the sabotage. Carter kicks Gideon out to find more beans.
- Randi offers a makeshift coffee solution. Carter asks if it will work. Randi says nope.
Act 2
- Kat is furiously scrubbing the bar clean. She finds moldy scones in all the wrong places.
- Max makes drinks and ushers the old out making sure they don’t bother other patrons.
- Kat is fielding conversations from some drunk elders trying not to snap from the stress.
- Gideon comes in at the worst time to ask Kat where he can find espresso beans.
- Kat is busy and tells Gideon the beans are sold at Corks and Orcs instead of beside them.
- Gideon heads out excited that orcs exist yet apprehensive about facing one himself.
- Max gets an important call from his agent and tells Kat he has to step out for a bit.
- One of Sheila’s drunk friends accidentally slings a cold french fry right into Kat’s eye.
- Carter is frantically pressing five different French Presses. Randi is making drip coffee.
- Carter is snapping at all of the customers. Some influencers are displeased by his work.
- Carter keeps trying to manage Randi, but she retaliates by pointing out his mistakes.
- All of the served cafe customers are loudly complaining about their watered down coffee.
- Cats are all around the kitchen hissing at the dogs who came from a puppy yoga class.
- Carter starts having mild allergic reactions to all of the animals and spilling everything.
- Gideon returns all dressed up as Gandalf the White with Potter’s glasses and a light saber.
- Carter asks Gideon for the beans, but he was distracted by Corks and Orcs and forgot.
- Randi lashes out at Gideon about the espresso beans. Gideon runs to the kitchen upset.
- More tension mounts as Carter snaps at Randi that they could have used Gideon’s help.
- Carter convinces Randi to have a heart to heart with Gideon, who offers a fix to the mess.
- Max comes back and sees Kat in distress. He tells her to have a seat and to let him help.
- Kat sits down and spills about all the pain points – unruly drunks; lost payment; no cats.
- Max sympathizes with Kat and says that’s a reason why he’s pursuing his singing career.
- Kat announces how there’s no way she’ll be able to satisfy the young health inspector.
- Sheila hears this and is flattered by the “young” compliment. She decides to tell the truth.
- Cut to Sheila making a call and putting on a fake voice pretending to be the inspector.
- Kat deadpans to the camera, gives up, and goes to ring the Last Call bell way too early.
- Gideon fixes the watered down coffees turning them into his famous Amish coffee soup.
- The coffee soup and friendship bread are offered discounted and both are well received.
- Kat, Max, and Sheila return to the cafe. Kat tells Carter she closed the bar and folds.
- Carter is pleased to have won, but also launches into an apology about how hard it was.
Post-Credits Stinger
- Kat, Max, Randi, and Gideon are all at a bar table playing Jumanji. Sheila comments.
- Kat watches in awe for a bit while Carter does his work, not daring to complain.
- Carter flatly reminds Kat about the toilets. Kat shrugs, smiles, and waves to the camera.